📘 CodingMarble Learn

Relative Clauses: who, which, that and whose

A relative clause is a small sentence that describes a noun. It starts with a relative pronoun: who (people), which (things), that (people or things, defining only) and whose (belonging). A clause with no commas is needed to identify the noun (defining); a clause with commas adds extra information (non-defining). We can leave out who/which/that when it is the object of the clause.

🎬 Step-by-step story

  1. Four people stand here. If we say "the woman", which one? We need more information.
  2. who is for people: "the woman who teaches us". The who-part joins the noun and tells us which one.
  3. which and that are for things: "the book that I read". That also works for people.
  4. whose shows belonging: "the girl whose bag is red". The arrow goes from the girl to her bag.
  5. The comma game: no commas means the clause is needed; commas mean extra information that can be removed.
  6. Free play: press who, which, that or whose. The one that fits glows and you see a full sentence.

Tip: drag the 3D scene to turn it. Use two fingers to zoom.

🤔 Common doubts, cleared

Why do we need a relative clause at all?

A noun alone can be unclear. The clause tells which one. In the 3D, four people look alike until the who-part picks one.

Can I say "the woman which teaches us"?

It sounds wrong. Which is for things. For people use who (or that in defining clauses).

Are which and that the same?

In defining clauses, often yes. After a comma use which, not that.

Is whose only for people?

Mostly, but you can use it for things too: a house whose roof is red.

How do I know if I need commas?

Ask: if I remove the clause, do we still know who or what? Yes means commas; no means no commas.

What if more than one word fits?

Press who and that together: both glow for people. Press which and that: both glow for things.

What is a relative clause?

A clause is a group of words with a subject and a verb. A relative clause describes a noun and starts with a relative pronoun. It comes right after the noun it describes.

Example: The woman who teaches us is kind. ("who teaches us" tells which woman.)

who, which, that, whose

WordUseExample
whopeopleHe is the man who helped us.
whichthings, animalsThis is the book which I read.
thatpeople or things (defining)The film that we saw was long.
whosebelongingShe is the girl whose bag is red.
where / whenplace / timeThe school where she studies is old.

Defining or non-defining: the comma rule

Defining (no commas): needed to know which person or thing. "The student who won is my friend." Take it out and we do not know which student.

Non-defining (commas): extra information; the noun is already clear. "Tom, who won, is my friend." Here we cannot use that.

Leaving out the pronoun, and describing role models

When the pronoun is the object of the clause, we may leave it out: "The book (that) I read is old." But keep it when it is the subject: "The man who helped us" (not "the man helped us").

Describing a role model: name + who + what they do + why you admire them. Example: Dr Kalam, who was a scientist, is a person whom many students admire because he kept learning.

Key formulas and definitions

Worked examples

1. Join: She is a teacher. She inspires us.

She is a teacher who inspires us.

2. Join: This is the phone. I bought it yesterday.

This is the phone (that/which) I bought yesterday. The pronoun is the object, so it can be left out.

3. Join: I met a girl. Her father is a pilot.

I met a girl whose father is a pilot.

Common mistakes

Practice quiz

1. The woman ____ teaches us is kind.
2. This is the book ____ I read.
3. The girl ____ bag is red is my cousin.
4. Which has an extra-information clause?
5. Which pronoun can NOT be dropped?

Practice: answer these yourself

Type or choose your answer, then press Check. Use a hint if you are stuck; the full solution appears after you answer.

Frequently asked questions

What is the difference between who and whom?

Who is the subject (the man who helped us). Whom is the object and is formal (the man whom we helped). In everyday English people say who or drop it.

Can I use that for people?

Yes in defining clauses: the girl that lives next door. Not after a comma.

What are attributive clauses?

The same idea: a clause placed beside a noun to describe it. In English grammar we call them relative clauses.

Where this is taught

China九年级(初三)Sem.1 Unit 2 Inspiring People

Learn first

Related lessons

All Social Science lessons